This page will look anterior cervical discectomy and fusion (ACDF) as a surgical treatment for chronic back pain and how it can impact your personal injury settlement. ACDF is a specialized procedure where a spinal disc is removed to relieve pressure on the nerve roots, helping to alleviate persistent pain.
ACDF Surgery
Anterior cervical discectomy and fusion (ACDF) is a surgical procedure used to treat conditions in the cervical spine (neck), often aimed at relieving pressure on the spinal cord or nerve roots caused by issues like herniated discs, degenerative disc disease, or spinal stenosis. The surgery involves two main steps:
- Discectomy: The damaged or herniated disc is removed from between the vertebrae to reduce pressure on the nerves or spinal cord.
- Fusion: After the disc is removed, the space between the vertebrae is stabilized by inserting a bone graft or implant. This encourages the bones to fuse together, providing stability and preventing further movement in that section of the spine.
ACDF is typically recommended when non-surgical treatments like physical therapy, medications, or injections fail to provide relief. The procedure is known to be effective for conditions causing chronic neck pain, radiating arm pain, numbness, or weakness. Recovery may vary, but many patients experience significant relief from their symptoms following the surgery.
This frontal approach offers two main advantages. First, it allows the surgeon direct visualization of the affected cervical discs and full access to most of the cervical spine. It also provides a clear, straightforward pathway for disc removal. Second, the anterior approach typically results in less post-operative pain and fewer complications compared to a posterior operation.
In the initial phase of an ACDF procedure, the damaged spinal disc is removed. The second phase involves performing a fusion surgery immediately afterward. During the fusion, an implant or bone graft is placed in the space where the disc was removed, replacing the disc and providing stability and strength to the spine.
What is ACDF Surgery For?
ACDF surgery is commonly performed to treat herniated discs in the cervical spine. A herniated disc occurs when a spinal disc ruptures, allowing the inner gel-like material to leak out, which can pinch or compress nearby nerves, causing pain. ACDF helps alleviate chronic pain from a cervical herniated disc by removing the affected disc.
While primarily used for herniated discs, ACDF is also an effective treatment for degenerative cervical disc disease. Additionally, it can sometimes be used to address symptoms associated with cervical spinal stenosis and bone spurs caused by arthritis.
What are the Risks of ACDF Surgery?
ACDF surgery is generally considered safe and effective, but like any surgical procedure, it carries certain risks and potential complications. Some of the most common risks and complications associated with ACDF include:
Infection: Although rare, infections can occur at the incision site or around the surgical area, requiring antibiotics or additional surgery.
Nerve Damage: There is a risk of injury to the spinal cord or surrounding nerves during surgery, which can lead to symptoms such as numbness, weakness, or, in very rare cases, paralysis.
Difficulty Swallowing (Dysphagia): Post-surgical difficulty swallowing is common in the first few weeks after surgery, but it usually improves with time.
Non-Union (Failed Fusion): In some cases, the vertebrae may not properly fuse after surgery, resulting in a condition called non-union or pseudarthrosis. This may require additional surgery.
Adjacent Segment Disease (ASD): Over time, the fused section of the spine can place added stress on the adjacent vertebrae, potentially leading to degeneration or herniation in those areas.
Aside from these specific risk, there are risks related to general anesthesia, including allergic reactions, breathing problems, or heart complications.
ACDF Surgery and Car Accidents
Car accidents are a common cause of cervical spine injuries, which can eventually lead to ACDF surgery. The violent forces experienced during a car accident, such as whiplash, can result in various spinal injuries, including:
Herniated Discs: A sudden impact can cause a spinal disc to rupture or herniate, putting pressure on nearby nerves or the spinal cord, leading to pain, numbness, or weakness in the arms and neck. If conservative treatments fail, ACDF surgery may be required to remove the damaged disc and stabilize the spine.
Fractures or Dislocations: Severe accidents can fracture or dislocate cervical vertebrae, potentially damaging the spinal cord or nerves. In some cases, ACDF is used to stabilize the spine after these types of injuries, promoting healing and preventing further damage.
Spinal Cord Compression: The force of a crash can cause spinal misalignment or bone fragments to press against the spinal cord, resulting in neurological symptoms. ACDF may be recommended to relieve pressure on the spinal cord and protect its function.
Degenerative Disc Disease Aggravation: In some cases, car accidents can exacerbate pre-existing spinal conditions, such as degenerative disc disease, by accelerating disc deterioration or triggering painful symptoms that require surgical intervention.
For individuals who suffer cervical spine injuries due to a car accident, ACDF surgery can provide relief from chronic pain, numbness, and mobility issues by stabilizing the spine and decompressing the nerves. The decision to undergo surgery is typically made when non-surgical treatments, such as physical therapy, pain management, or bracing, fail to alleviate symptoms.
Linking ACDF Surgery to Car Accident Injuries
A lot of the time, its very obvious that a car accident directly led to the need for ACDF surgery. However, there are situations where you’ll need the best car accident lawyer to prove that the crash caused the injury requiring surgery. Legal challenges often arise when the defense argues that the injuries were pre-existing or not entirely caused by the accident. Discrepancies in medical records or delays in seeking treatment can further complicate these claims. Plaintiffs can build a solid case with expert medical testimony evidence to show that their ACDF was caused by the car accident. This will increase the compensation for their losses.
Expert testimony from medical professionals is particularly critical. A skilled doctor must clearly explain the necessity of ACDF surgery and its direct connection to the car accident. Detailed accident reports, property damage assessments, and immediate post-accident medical evaluations also play a vital role in strengthening the plaintiff’s case by demonstrating the severity of the impact and the injuries sustained.
Settlement Value of ACDF Surgery in Injury Cases
The settlement value for an ACDF (anterior cervical discectomy and fusion) surgery following a car accident can vary widely depending on several factors. These factors help determine the compensation a plaintiff may receive in a personal injury lawsuit or insurance claim. Some key factors that affect the settlement value include:
- Severity of Injuries: The extent of the spinal injury and how it affects your daily life, ability to work, and overall quality of life can significantly impact the settlement value. More severe or permanent injuries generally result in higher compensation.
- Medical Expenses: The cost of ACDF surgery itself, along with any additional medical expenses such as hospital stays, rehabilitation, follow-up treatments, and ongoing care, is a major factor in calculating settlements. This also includes future medical costs if further treatment or surgery is needed.
- Lost Income: If the injury led to time off work or affected your ability to return to your previous job, you may be entitled to compensation for lost wages and reduced earning potential.
- Pain and Suffering: Compensation for pain and suffering is often awarded in personal injury cases. This accounts for the physical pain, discomfort, and emotional distress caused by the injury and surgery.
- Impact on Daily Life: If the injury and subsequent surgery have long-term effects on your ability to perform daily activities or hobbies, the settlement value may increase to reflect the diminished quality of life.
- Strength of Evidence: The clearer the evidence linking the car accident to the injury, the stronger the case, which can lead to higher settlements. If expert medical testimony, accident reports, and other documentation clearly demonstrate that the accident caused the need for ACDF surgery, it strengthens the plaintiff’s position.
- Pre-Existing Conditions: If the defendant argues that the injury was pre-existing or not entirely caused by the accident, it could affect the settlement value. Plaintiffs with strong medical evidence showing that the accident aggravated or caused the injury are more likely to secure higher compensation.
ACDF Settlement Payour Ranges
Minor: In less severe cases, settlements can range from $600,000 to $150,000.
Moderate: In cases where injuries are more serious or lead to long-term effects, settlements can fall between $180,000 and $400,000.
High End: In cases involving permanent disability or significant impact on the plaintiff’s life, settlements can exceed $500,000, and in rare cases, may reach over $1 million.
ACDF Surgery Verdicts and Settlements
$427,500 Verdict (Florida 2024): The plaintiff, a 45-year-old construction worker, claimed his vehicle was rear-ended by the defendant. The plaintiff, according to counsel, had a prior history of hip surgery and suffered a neck injury and re-injured his hip. He reportedly underwent ACDF surgery approximately 3 years after the accident and hip surgery approximately 4 years after the collision. The plaintiff allegedly suffered complications after his hip surgery and required a second surgery. This case is an example of how prior ACDF surgery can increase the severity of accident injuries.
$3,000,000 Settlement (Missouri 2024): A tractor-trailer rear-ended the plaintiff on Interstate 70 in St. Louis. The plaintiff received chiropractic treatment, physical therapy, and ultimately had a cervical spine stimulator implanted. Complications from the procedure, including bleeding, necessitated its removal and a subsequent spinal fusion, leading to permanent pain and limitations. The defense contended that the sudden traffic stop caused only minor impact and that the treating provider was responsible for the ongoing issues.
$12,200 Verdict (Illinois 2024): A pickup truck collided with a tractor-trailer, and the tractor-trailer driver initially didn’t seek treatment, continuing his route. Ten days later, he sought urgent care for headaches, neck, and lower back pain, followed by more treatment six days after. An MRI revealed a cervical syrinx at C4/C5, leading to surgeries, including syrinx fenestration, C5-C6 fusion, and C4-C5 laminectomy. At trial, the plaintiff testified, while the defendant admitted negligence for the crash but argued that the syrinx and related injuries were not caused by the accident, citing the minor impact and delayed treatment.
$550,000 Settlement (Idaho 2023): The plaintiff was struck when the defendant failed to yield on a left-turn. The plaintiff suffered a neck injury at C6-7 requiring surgery for an anterior cervical discectomy and fusion (ACDF) with allograft. Right shoulder injury requiring surgery for rotator cuff repair, subacromial decompression, distal clavicle excision, and biceps tenodesis.
$400,121 Verdict (Oregon 2022): The plaintiff was stopped for pedestrian traffic at a crosswalk when the defendant rear-ended her at 20 mph. Plaintiff suffered a whiplash injury and spent 3 years treating with conservative care, after which an MRI revealed that she had annular tears and ACDF surgery was recommended.
Contact Us About Back Injury Cases
If you injured your back in an accident, contact our national personal injury lawyers for a free case evaluation. Call us at 800-553-8082 or contact us online.